12 Most Overrated And Underrated Beauty Products Of 2017 So Far

If I'm being totally and completely honest with you, I'm definitely someone who follows the hype. I love watching Youtube videos that talk about the newest beauty trends and makeup products that makeup gurus are pining for. But over the years I've come to realize that there are so many incredibly expensive makeup products that are simply just overrated and not worth it.

I've made my mistakes and I'm still learning. So here I am to share with you my thoughts on some of 2017's most overrated makeup products and most underrated products.

Let me get one thing straight, if you love the overrated products, that's fine! Own it, girl! Everyone likes different things and at the end of the day, makeup is about whatever makes you feel good. But there are also tons of makeup underdogs that are absolutely phenomenal products but don't get enough credit and I want to share those with you.

If you're looking to expand your makeup collection and try some new products that you've never heard of, you've come to the right place. We've got tons of super underrated, but fantastic makeup products from high end to drugstore and everything in between.

What're you looking for?

Face ☺️

Eyes 👁

Lips 💄

If you want to check out more articles like this one, read 17 Makeup Products That Are Totally Worth The Hype VS Those That Aren't where we compare super Insta and Youtube famous makeup products that are must-haves and those that you could probably pass on.

Click "Next" for face products.

Water Blend Face & Body Foundation // Makeup Forever

Price: $54

Don't get me wrong, I love me some Makeup Forever. They have some of the best waterproof eyeliners and face primers, but their new Water Blend Foundation seems to miss the mark when it comes to good foundations. The foundation is composed of 80% water, so they're not lying or anything, but the coverage seems to be so light that it's like you haven't even really put on foundation. If a foundation is going to be sooo light coverage, I'd rather opt for no foundation at all.

Verdict: Overrated

via @tiptophk

The Sculpting Contour Powder // Kevyn Aucoin

Price: $53

There is so much hype around Kevyn Aucoin's Sculpting Contour Powder in the beauty community, it's a little crazy. And as much as Kevyn Aucoin is known for making professional quality products, the Scultping Powder doesn't seem to cut it for me. I'm all for a cool tone contour, but this powder is suuuper cool tone. It may be great for very fair skin types who have cool skin tones, but if you're a bit more tan, this could just end up looking dirty on your face.

Verdict: Overrated

via @_mybeautyfavorites_

MegaGlo Highlighting Powder // Wet n Wild

Price: $7

Kylighters can move aside because Wet n Wild's MegaGlo highlighters are absolutely blinding. They are super inexpensive but so pigmented and glowy. And if you're looking for Kylighter dupes, the Megaglo shade in "Precious Petals" is exactly the same as Kylie's "Cotton Candy Cream".

Verdict: Underrated

Studio Fix Perfecting Powder // MAC

Price: $33

Everyone knows and loves MAC's Studio Fix Foundation, but seriously why has nobody ever mentioned the loose powder form? The Studio Fix Perfecting Powder is a semi-translucent loose powder that's so finely milled and is so versatile - you can use it to bake, to set foundation, or even over bare skin to give you that no makeup makeup look. It's so long lasting, does not get cakey, and the best part, there are so many shade options.

Verdict: Underrated

via @decoise_shop

Blush in Mendocino // Cargo

Price: $32

Why does the beauty community hardly ever speak of Cargo blushes? Their blushes are so beautiful, so creamy and so pigmented, and there's also a lot of product in one pan. The blush in shade Mendocino is super comparable to NARS' Laguna blush...but perhaps even better.

Verdict: Underrated

Click "Next" for eyes.

Eyeshadow Primer Potion // Urban Decay

Price: $28

It pains me to say this because I actually love the Urban Decay Primer Potion. It's been in my makeup bag for years ever since I started wearing makeup, and I still use it today. But the truth is, there are so many eyeshadow primers on the market that are just as good and more affordable. So if you're currently using it great, but if you want a cheaper alternative, try ELF Shadow Lock Eyelid Primer or Wet n Wild Take On The Day Eyeshadow Primer.

Verdict: Overrated

via @kyliecosmetics

Kyshadow Palettes // Kylie Cosmetics

Price: $53 - $68

There's nothing particularly wrong or bad about Kylie's eyeshadow palettes, but there's also nothing particularly outstanding either. The palettes are pretty standard bronze, purples, and browns, that are quite easy to find elsewhere for a much more affordable price and the quality is not amazing, but it's also not bad. So unless you're a die-hard Kylie Jenner fan, personally I would recommend giving these products a pass.

Verdict: Overrated

via @inglot_cosmetics

Freedom System Eyeshadows // Inglot

Price: $12 per shadow

Okay, so I get that palettes are super convenient because you have someone who's already chosen a colour scheme for you, but choosing your own colours to create your personalized palette can be even better...because you know you're going to love every shade. Inglot has this super cool Freedom System where you can individually choose each eyeshadow and build your own palette, and the best part is that all their shadows are so high quality, so creamy, and so pigmented. I never hear people talking about Inglot products unless their professional makeup artists, so come on fam, it's time we got on this ish!

Verdict: Underrated

via @doyanmakeup

Brow Stylist Definer // L'Oreal

Price: $12

This eyebrow product does not get enough attention that it deserves. L'Oreal's Brow Stylist is a double ended eyebrow pencil with a spoolie on the other end. It creates such a natural looking brow and it's totally comparable to Anastasia Beverly Hills' Brow Wiz. One downside is that there are only three shades available, but if the shade suits you, I guarantee you will never spend $30 on a brow pencil again.

Verdict: Underrated

Click "Next" for lips.

Ultra Matte Lip Liquid Lipsticks // Colour Pop

Price: $6

Colour Pop's liquid lippies took Youtube and Instagram by storm, and they make tons of beautiful shades for a super affordable price. However, as much as I want to like them, as many liquid lipsticks are, they tend to be rather drying. Especially during the fall, anything drying I'll have to say no thank you.

Verdict: Overrated

via @soulatigirl

Aqua Lip Waterproof Lipliner Pencil // Makeup Forever

Price: $24

Not that Makeup Forever aren't already stars, but when it comes to their Aqua Lip Lipliners they outshine everyone. They're not widely talked about on the internet, but they are so pigmented, super long lasting, and don't bleed. They even work really well as a base for your lipstick and aren't drying.

Verdict: Underrated

via @rimmellondonus

Lasting Finish Kate Moss Nude Collection Lipsticks // Rimmel

Price: $7

Rimmel's Lasting Finish Kate Moss Nude Lipsticks are some of the best nude lipsticks ever. They come in a variety of shades for fair and deep skin tones, and they're super low maintenance. You don't have to be anxious about your lipstick getting stuck to your teeth or having to reapply every hour.

Verdict: Underrated

Sephora Canada's Huge Holiday Sale Starts Today & This Is Your Sign To Treat Yourself

All Beauty Insiders can save 20% no matter what tier they are!

Narcity may receive a small commission if you purchase something we recommend in this article, which was created by the Narcity Shop team. Items are in stock and prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time.

If you're still looking for a gift for the beauty lover in your life (or if you just want to treat yourself to something on payday) then you can head to Sephora Canada because you can get 20% off your entire purchase right now.

Keep Reading Show less

Narcity may receive a small commission if you purchase something we recommend in this article, which was created by the Narcity Shop team. Items are in stock and prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time.

With just three weeks left until Christmas and other holidays already starting, you may still be wondering what to get your loved ones. You can find some amazing gifts under $50 but for those lucky few on your list, you may have allotted a bigger budget.

Keep Reading Show less

The Best Cyber Monday Beauty Deals You Can Find In Canada

Save big on brands like MERIT, Tatcha, YSL and get a ton of freebies!💄

Narcity may receive a small commission if you purchase something we recommend in this article, which was created by the Narcity Shop team. Items are in stock and prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time.

Beauty lovers, get excited! Today is Cyber Monday and your favourite brands have launched some of their best deals of the year. Whether you love makeup, skincare, haircare or fragrance, these are some of the best beauty deals you can find in Canada right now.

Keep Reading Show less

Narcity may receive a small commission if you purchase something we recommend in this article, which was created by the Narcity Shop team. Items are in stock and prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time.

One of the biggest hair trends of 2021 was the reemergence of curtain bangs. While they look good in theory, figuring out how to style them is a whole other ballgame. Some people use a round brush and blow dryer while others use the coveted but pricey Dyson Airwrap.

Keep Reading Show less