EN - Eat and Drink

There's An Amish Village Restaurant In Florida & They Serve The Freshest Homemade Pies

Did someone say homemade Amish pies? We did!

If you are looking for a foodie adventure, there is a place not far from the beach where tradition has not left the kitchen. Yoder's Restaurant is the place in Sarasota where you will find Amish village inspired food and knickknacks in Florida.

The restaurant is best known for its Mom-style homemade Amish pies and made-from-scratch home cooking. The Amish Village has been featured in the Food Network due to its traditional recipe and roots.

These pies are baked every morning from scratch and the restaurant offers dozens of flavors for the foodie adventurer. From fresh apple pie to fresh strawberry pie, this restaurant could be well named the king of pies.

Peanut Butter Pie is Yoder's most popular pie which contains peanut butter crumb, vanilla pudding, an extra layer of peanut butter crumb and whipped cream topping.

Each bite of these pies is like heaven. Yoder's make about 150 to 200 pies a day and about 8,000 pies for Thanksgiving Day.

You can never go wrong with key lime pie at this place. Yoder's Restaurant also offers seasonal and holiday pies such as blueberry crumb, Dutch apple crumb, baked peach, sugar-free apple and more.

Each seasonal pie is 10 inches and serves six to eight people. The price for 8" pie is $14.95 and for a 10" pie is $19.95.

Yoder's Restaurant and Amish Village

Address: 3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL 34239

Hours: Monday - Saturday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m

Why you need to go: This is one of the best pies in Sarasota county.