Please complete your profile to unlock commenting and other important features.

Please select your date of birth for special perks on your birthday. Your username will be your unique profile link and will be publicly used in comments.
Narcity Pro

This is a Pro feature.

Time to level up your local game with Narcity Pro.

Pro

$5/month

$40/year

  • Everything in the Free plan
  • Ad-free reading and browsing
  • Unlimited access to all content including AI summaries
  • Directly support our local and national reporting and become a Patron
  • Cancel anytime.
For Pro members only Pro
Summary

9 Private Islands For Sale In Ontario That Cost Less Than The Average Toronto Home

The views are dreamy and the living's easy.
Contributor

Somebody pinch us, we must be dreaming. There are so many spectacular Ontario private islands for sale and they’re cheaper than the average Toronto home. So if you want to make your tropical dreams come true, now might be your chance. 

According to a recent study on popular real estate site Zolo, the average cost of a Toronto home comes in around a whopping $1 million. 

While the 6ix is full of some truly gorgeous homes, not many of us have that much money lying around. 

Luckily, Ontario is filled with private islands that you can buy for less than $900,000.

Some are even as low as $599,000, which we know is still a fair chunk of cash. But the payoff definitely feels worth it.

That’s right, you can get away from it all and be the ruler of your own kingdom on one of these beautiful islands.

From the shores of the Georgian Bay to the secluded Lake of the Woods, there are plenty of dreamy locations that are sure to float your boat.

So it might be time to say so long to city life and hello to island living.

Hartman Island

Price: $614,900

Address: Sans Souci, Georgian Bay, ON

Description: You can enjoy a private swimming area and a cottage that features a fireplace, cathedral ceiling, and floor-to-ceiling windows.

View Here

Freedrinks Island

Price: $599,000

Address: Georgian Bay, ON

Description: Did someone say free drinks? We're in! This secluded island already has a charming cottage on site and gorgeous rocky shores for you to enjoy.

View Here

Lizard Island

Price: $800,000

Address: Lake Superior Provincial Park, ON

Description: The possibilities are endless with this non-developed island. You could build your own personal paradise from the ground up here. 

View Here

Horseshoe Island

Price: $785,000

Address: Georgian Bay, ON

Description: This is another non-developed island that you could do so much with. There are wonderful water views and elevated areas for building a cute seasonal cottage.

View Here

Shore Island

Price: $775,000

Address: Lake of the Woods, ON

Description: This beautifully maintained island features an incredible boat house with sleeping accommodations and a stunning sundeck where you can kick back and enjoy island living.

View Here

Black Sturgeon Island

Price: $695,000

Address: Lake of the Woods, ON

Description: This fish-shaped island features a charming cottage hidden within the trees and a 3,350-foot shoreline where you can soak up all the views.

View Here

Duval Island 

Price: $659,428.50

Address: Echo Bay, ON

Description: This gem of an island features a move-in-ready cottage, a guest cabin for your besties, walking trails, and tons of fruits and flowers for you to forage. 

View Here

Private Island South

Price: $659,428.50

Address: Lake of the Woods, ON

Description: This island is located in “Unorganized Territory,” meaning you won't face any building permits or design restrictions. As an added bonus, taxes here are lower than most.

View Here

Beulah Island

Price: $890,000

Address: Sans Souci, Georgian Bay, ON

Description: Located in the attractive cottage community of Sans Souci, this little island has everything you need for a summer getaway including stunning emerald waters.

View Here

  • Amber Van Wort was a writer at Narcity Canada. She studied journalism at Durham College in Oshawa and holds a special place in her heart for the Toronto Maple Leafs. She continues to be published in the Chicago Tribune, Best Reviews, and previously, The Belleville Intelligencer, totaling up to 9+ years of experience.

7 dreamy waterfront Airbnbs in Ontario that are like your own private resort

Complete with dreamy water views and cozy interiors.

This enchanting small town set on a BC island was named among North America's 'most peaceful'

Sandy beaches, ancient forests and a cozy town — anyone?. 🌲

This Ontario gem with waterfront towns and beaches is one of Canada's 'best' spots to live

It has "large" homes "priced much lower" than major Canadian cities.

New data reveals the 'most peaceful' places to live and Canadian towns demolished US ones

Five Canadian towns were named the most serene on the continent. 🍁