A Former NHL Player Is Suing The Canadian Hockey League Over Disturbing Hazing & Abuse

He alleges that management knew what was happening.
Contributor

Playing minor league hockey should be an exciting and positive start to someone's athletic career. However former NHLer Daniel Carcillo claims that his experience was a largely negative one, filled with disturbing hazing rituals. He outlines these alleged occurrences in a new class-action lawsuit.

The suit, which was filed with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice and electronically issued on June 18, lists Carcillo and former Lethbridge Hurricanes player Garrett Taylor as plaintiffs.

The defendants include the Canadian Hockey League, along with the CHL, OHL, WHL, and QMJHL and all of the teams in those organizations.

The content of the lawsuit alleges that the Canadian Hockey league is "plagued by rampant hazing, bullying, and abuse of underage players, by coaches, team staff and senior players."

It continues saying that the defendants in the case did not respond accordingly to this abuse, and instead perpetuated a toxic environment.

Carcillo goes into detail about the abuse he says he experienced during his time as a Sarnia Sting rookie in 2002. 

This includes a number of different physical abuses, including being beaten with goalie sticks and belts, as well as being forced into sexual acts during events organized by more senior players. Abuses also took place during team trips for away games.

Carcillo notes that the team's management and coaches were aware of the various abuses and did not try to stop them.

In one case, he alleges that a coach actually took part in the physical beating of a rookie player.

Taylor claims he was forced by his coach to fight other rookie players during practices, and that he suffered a concussion during one of these fights.

Both players also allege that a number of racist, homophobic, and sexist slurs were constantly directed toward the rookie players.

The CHL has not yet commented on these allegations. Carcillo first detailed the various abuses he experienced in a 2018 interview with the Canadian Press (via CTV News).

  • Colin Leggett was a Contributing Editor with Narcity Canada. He wrote on the national news team for over a year and contributed to coverage of the 2019 Canadian Federal Election, as well as the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic. Colin has a Bachelor's Degree in Communications and Cultural Theory from McMaster University, as well as a graduate certificate in Television Writing and Producing from Humber College. He is an avid consumer of politics and pop culture, having written about everything from food to television to Canada-U.S. relations.

The White House released an AI video insulting Canada and Brady Tkachuk is firing back

The video depicts the Ottawa Senators captain calling Canadians "maple syrup eating f---s."

An Ontario regional chair resigned amid claims he has a signed copy of Hitler's 'Mein Kampf'

He says he's a "passionate historian" who owns many pieces of historical art and artifacts.

Carney travels to India as Sikh Canadians warn about threats from the Indian government

Canadian Sikhs are calling on Carney to take a firmer stand on India.

'Big daddy' Mark Carney has gone viral worldwide after doing the Heated Rivalry 'leg thing'

It's raised questions about Canada's level of "media training." 💀

A storm is forecast to drop up to 20 cm of snow in southern Ontario by this weekend

"Prepare for quickly changing and deteriorating travel conditions."

I'm a newcomer to Toronto and this is what locals get wrong about the TTC

Here's why Torontonians don't know how good they have it. 👇

I moved from Ontario to Alberta and these 6 things cost me way less now

Calgary is WAY cheaper than Ottawa, allow me to explain...💰

Trump just launched a trade investigation into Canada and it could lead to even more tariffs

They're looking for "unreasonable or discriminatory" trading practices.

Unemployment rates in Canada very so much by city — Here's where they stand in February 2026

Here's a quick glance at unemployment rates for February, by Canadian city.

Conservatives are pushing a 'stand your ground' style law for home invasions

The law would protect people from being charged for acting in self-defence during a break-in.