Two US Subway Employees Were Shot & One Died Over 'Too Much Mayo' On A Sandwich

"There was something wrong with the sandwich," police said.

A sandwich with mayonnaise on it. Right: An Atlanta PD officer outside a Subway.

A sandwich with mayonnaise on it. Right: An Atlanta PD officer outside a Subway.

Interim Deputy Editor (News)

One Subway worker has died, and another is in critical condition after a shooting at a store in Atlanta, where police say an angry customer opened fire over his sandwich toppings.

More specifically, he thought they put too much mayonnaise on it.

The bizarre and fatal shooting happened Sunday evening around 6:30 p.m., according to police.

They say the suspect had a handgun on him, and he didn't know how to resolve a dispute over his toppings, so he pulled the weapon out and started shooting.

“There was something wrong with the sandwich that made him so upset that he decided to take out his anger on two of the employees here,” Atlanta Police department Deputy Chief Charles Hampton Jr. said in a media update on Monday.

Police say a 26-year-old woman was shot and killed in the dispute. Another woman, 24, was critically injured and later taken to hospital where she was still recovering on Monday.

Both were working shifts at the store, and the 24-year-old had her young child, 5, in the restaurant at the time.

"It just breaks my heart to know that someone has the audacity to point a weapon and shoot someone for as little as too much mayonnaise on a sandwich," Willie Glenn, co-owner of the Subway store, told WSB-TV.

Darin Schierbaum, Atlanta's interim chief of police, said arguments have led to most of the homicides in the city this year, and this is just another case of it.

"An argument leads to someone picking up a weapon and firing that gun, leaving someone dead or someone critically injured," he said, per WSB-TV.

"We need individuals to talk out their disputes, walk away and do not pick up guns."

He added that police can step up their efforts to stop certain types of crime, such as robbery, but "we cannot stop someone who is mad because there is too much mayonnaise on their sandwich."

Authorities arrested a 36-year-old man in connection with the case on Sunday, said Hampton.

His identity was not immediately released.

This article's left-hand cover image was used for illustrative purposes only.

  • Interim Deputy Editor, News

    Josh Elliott (he/him) was the Interim Deputy Editor (News) for Narcity, where he led the talented editorial team's local news content. Josh previously led Narcity’s international coverage and he spent several years as a writer for CTV and Global News in the past. He earned his English degree from York University and his MA in journalism from Western University. Superhero content is his kryptonite.

CRA offers automatic tax filing and it could help 'put more money in your pocket'

You could be eligible for the service without even knowing it.

Canadian passport fees are going up this month and you'll pay more to get the travel document

"Fees for travel documents will be adjusted each year to align with inflation."

Mark Carney got publicly called out by a Liberal MP for his support of Iran strikes (VIDEO)

Liberal MP Will Greaves released a video openly criticizing Carney's stance.

Gene-edited pork has been approved in Canada but labels aren't mandatory

It's the only genetically modified meat approved for sale in Canada.

Ontario's safest cities for driving were revealed and you might not expect the top locations

It's based on accidents and infractions like distracted driving and speeding. 🚗

Foreign investment in Canada just hit its highest level in nearly 20 years

StatCan says more than half of last year's foreign investment came from the U.S.