A Super Mario Bros. Movie Got Announced & The Internet Is Already Trying To Re-Cast It

Robert De Niro and Al Pacino, step right up!

Staff Writer

The internet does not waste time when it is upset, which is why it's no surprise that plenty of people have already suggested different casting options for the new Super Mario Bros. movie.

The film, which was only announced by Nintendo on Thursday, September 23, is set to debut on December 21, 2022, with a star-studded cast — but not the cast that people online would like.

The A-list voice cast for the animated films includes Chris Pratt as Mario, Anya Taylor-Joy as Peach, Charlie Day as Luigi, Jack Black as Bowser, and Seth Rogen as Donkey Kong.

The biggest point of contention for people seemed to be Pratt as Mario, a role that some people said should've gone to Danny DeVito, while others suggested a classic Italian-American pairing of Robert De Niro and Al Pacino as Mario and Luigi.

Pratt posted on Instagram to say that it was a "dream" to play the role (he's a fan of the OG Super Mario games) and even tried his hand at a Mario voice, albeit not the one he's actually using in the movie.

It's not all bad for the voice actors, however, because the casting of Jack Black and Seth Rogen as Bowser and Donkey Kong respectively seems to be going over well.

So well, in fact, that someone edited Rogen's iconic laugh over a video of DK and, well, the casting director might've nailed this one.

  • Cormac O'Brien was an Associate Editor at Narcity Canada, covering all things exciting and trending about Canada. He has a Bachelor of Fine Arts in Creative Writing and Journalism from the University of Victoria, where he served as the Editor-in-Chief of the campus newspaper and was awarded the BCYNA Community News Scholarship for his writing. He was also the producer and co-host of Now On Narcity, Narcity's flagship podcast.

A burst of snow will bring up to 20 cm to Ontario this week before the cold snap ends

Temperatures will warm up but still be cold enough for "lingering" snow.

CSIS is hiring for these jobs and you can get paid up to $120,000 a year to be nosy

You'll help investigate threats to national security. 🔍

Costco is hiring for jobs that pay $20 to $25 an hour and some don't require any experience

Positions are available at a new unique warehouse that's opening in Canada soon.

6 cheap and safe Caribbean destinations to visit in 2026 if you're skipping Cuba

Turquoise waters, white sands, and no travel warnings. 😌🏝️

U of T is the only Canadian school in the top 10 of this new best universities ranking

It beat every Canadian university in all of these subject areas! 📚

Lotto 6/49 winners split a $5M jackpot with another ticket and didn't believe it was real

They checked the ticket online and at a store to make sure they really won the jackpot. 💸

Canada's 'most romantic town' is near Toronto and it's filled with European charm

It's the perfect place to visit with your favourite person.