This 200-Year-Old Toronto Scandal Is Basically A 'Bridgerton' Plotline In Real Life

Featuring a lady's besmirched honour and a duel (but without the good-looking actors).
Staff Writer

The elegant and romantic Netflix series Bridgerton is hugely popular all across the world right now, but did you know that Toronto once had its own version of Bridgerton play out in real life?

In 18th-century Toronto, two high-ranking government officials duelled to the death in the name of a woman's honour, which will sound super familiar to anyone who's binge-watched the show.

Editor's Choice: Here's How Canadians Are Modifying Their Tim Hortons Orders So They Taste Better

Unknown | Wikimedia

According to the Globe and Mail, Mr. John Small (pictured above) was a high-ranking government official living in Toronto in 1799, whose wife's honour was called into question by Mr. John White, Ontario's Attorney General at the time.

The Globe said Small's wife had "failed to give due attention" to Mr. White's wife at a ball, and so the Whites conspired against the Smalls by gossiping that Mrs. Small was sleeping around with other aristocrats — including Mr. White himself.

Mr. Small was not going to stand for his wife's besmirchment, so he challenged Mr. White to a duel.

"On January 3, 1800, Mr. Small shot and mortally wounded Mr. White," the Globe wrote, reporting that Mr. Small was acquitted at a murder trial a few weeks later.

But the Smalls were still ostracized from high society as a result of the duel, the Globe wrote, and rumours about Mrs. Small never went away.

Most Torontonians likely don't know who Mr. Small is, but they might recognize where his house once was — it's now the large glass Globe and Mail Centre on King St. E., according to the Globe.

This story might be super familiar to Bridgerton viewers, who — spoiler alert — watched Simon and Anthony duel in episode four over a perceived tarnishing of Daphne's honour.

Nobody died in Bridgerton's duel, which means that maybe Toronto's story is a little bit more exciting. Season two plotline, maybe?

  • Cormac O'Brien was an Associate Editor at Narcity Canada, covering all things exciting and trending about Canada. He has a Bachelor of Fine Arts in Creative Writing and Journalism from the University of Victoria, where he served as the Editor-in-Chief of the campus newspaper and was awarded the BCYNA Community News Scholarship for his writing. He was also the producer and co-host of Now On Narcity, Narcity's flagship podcast.

'Ken Killer' Paul Bernardo was sentenced 30 years ago — Here's where he is now

He is still one of Canada's most notorious serial killers.

11 gorgeous Toronto restaurants that locals say are always worth the splurge

Remember these spots for your next special occasion! 😍