Canada Considers Scrapping Lie Detector Tests After Reports Of Negative Results

They're used by Canada's intelligence agencies.
Canada Considers Scrapping Lie Detector Tests After Reports Of Negative Results
Erik Mclean I Pexels Ashkan Forouzani I Unsplash
Contributor

To tell you the truth, the federal government could possibly scrap lie detector tests in the future. Pun intended. 

The country is taking a second look at the use of polygraph tests, which are used mainly during security screenings, according to CBC News

Editor's Choice: 441,000 Canadians Have Been Contacted By The CRA About CERB Repayments

CSIS could not justify the merits of examiners — who are not medical practitioners — to ask medical-related questions of the people they examine. NSIRA

The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency (NSIRA), also known as the country's watchdog for intelligence agencies, brought forward a report that criticized the technique. 

For those unaware of how a polygraph works, it can supposedly tell if a person is lying based on their blood pressure and heart rate.

According to the report, all government employees who need enhanced security clearance for top-secret departments and projects have to undergo the test. 

Agencies like the Canadian Security Intelligence Service and the Communications Security Establishment reportedly use these methods on their employees.

The watchdog found that there was a lack of oversight in the program, doubt about the tests' accuracy and that there were blurred lines seen between polygraphs and "medical analyses". 

They also believe that these kinds of tests can be harmful to an employee's mental health if not administered in the right way.

The future of lie detectors in Canada will be reviewed by the NSIRA. 

  • Osobe Waberi was a Toronto-based Ethiopian-Somali Francophone writer at Narcity Canada. She graduated from the University of Toronto with a specialist degree in journalism and a news media diploma from Centennial College. Before Osobe’s gig as a national trending writer at Narcity, she worked at Toronto Star, The Canadian Press, VICE, and CBC.

A new Canadian bill would make it easier for police & CSIS to access your online data

The government says existing laws haven't kept pace with changes in technology.

Carney travels to India as Sikh Canadians warn about threats from the Indian government

Canadian Sikhs are calling on Carney to take a firmer stand on India.

7 ways the war in Iran could impact Canadians — from grocery prices to terrorism

As the conflict engulfs the broader Middle East, here are some possible implications for Canadians.

Mark Carney got publicly called out by a Liberal MP for his support of Iran strikes (VIDEO)

Liberal MP Will Greaves released a video openly criticizing Carney's stance.

5 things to know about Canadian Jeremy Hansen's trip to the moon tomorrow

He'll be the first non-American to travel beyond low Earth orbit! 🚀

First Nations chiefs demand an apology after Carney said he could 'outlast' a protestor

"Shame on him for laughing at people who are sick and bullying a woman, and shame on those who laughed along with him."

Mark Carney reaffirmed his promise to bring back Canada's popular $5,000 home upgrade grant

Carney promised a bunch of green incentives during the Liberal leadership race over a year ago — but they still haven't materialized.

Pierre Poilievre is pushing to cancel the planned Toronto–Quebec City high-speed rail

"This $90 billion Liberal boondoggle does not make sense and it does not make dollars."