Please complete your profile to unlock commenting and other important features.

Please select your date of birth for special perks on your birthday. Your username will be your unique profile link and will be publicly used in comments.
Narcity Pro

This is a Pro feature.

Time to level up your local game with Narcity Pro.

Pro

$5/month

$40/year

  • Everything in the Free plan
  • Ad-free reading and browsing
  • Unlimited access to all content including AI summaries
  • Directly support our local and national reporting and become a Patron
  • Cancel anytime.
For Pro members only Pro
Summary

7 of the spiciest moments you missed in Thursday's federal leaders' debate

Things are heating up. 🌶️

​Pierre Poilievre, Mark Carney and Jagmeet Singh on Thursday's debate stage.

Canada's federal leaders faced off in the second official leaders' debate Thursday night — and things got a bit spicy.

Christopher Katsarov via Leaders' Debates Commission | POOL
Contributor

Canada's four main federal party leaders went head-to-head in the English-language federal leaders' debate on Thursday — and with the 2025 federal election now less than two weeks away, things are heating up.

This was the second of the two official debates before Canadians head to the polls on April 28, following the French-language showdown on Wednesday night.

Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre, Liberal leader Mark Carney, NDP leader Jagmeet Singh and Bloc Québécois leader Yves-François Blanchet all took the stage in Montreal to talk tariffs, cost of living, climate, public safety and leadership in crisis.

The Green Party was initially slated to be there too but got dropped from both debates last minute for not meeting the candidate requirement.

And while Thursday's debate stayed relatively tame overall, it was still a notch spicier than the French one — with a few standout moments that definitely livened things up.

Here are seven of the boldest, funniest or just plain pettiest highlights from the English-language debate stage.

Blanchet calls Carney a 'real Canadian leader' (but sarcastically)

Things got cheeky early on when Yves-François Blanchet took aim at Mark Carney for flip-flopping on pipelines depending on who he was talking to.

"Mr. Carney, you are becoming a real Canadian leader, saying one thing in French and another in English," Blanchet said — sarcastically, of course.

Singh jokes that it's Poilievre's 'first time caring about the environment'

Jagmeet Singh came in hot during a discussion about energy and Bill C-69, throwing shade at Pierre Poilievre for wanting fewer rules around development.

"What Mr. Poilievre is saying is, 'Have no rules. Have no regulations. Have no controls over any energy development. Let big polluters pollute,'" Singh said.

Poilievre tried to clap back — "That is not true. In fact, Mr. Singh, the reality is we should have strong rules, enforced once —"

But Singh cut him off with, "That's the first time I've heard you care about the environment. Is that your new position?"

Even Carney couldn't hold back a laugh — the Liberal leader, whose podium was between Singh's and Poilievre's, could be seen and heard chuckling between them.

Blanchet drags Carney's past with a Brexit burn

Blanchet went in on Carney again — this time during the affordability segment — with a reference to Carney's past finance roles, including in the U.K.'s Brexit saga.

"You claim to have a lot of experience in many things," Blanchet began. "You say that you are a great crisis manager. Which one? I've heard of nothing. As far as I know, Brexit happened, even if you were against it."

"You say you are a great negotiator," Blanchet went on. "What have you negotiated, but fiscal paradises in Bermuda or Cayman Islands? You have to prove something [...] if you want people to believe you."

Singh and Poilievre squabble over housing math

In a fiery back-and-forth over housing numbers, Singh accused Poilievre of building just six affordable homes during his time as housing minister.

"False, 200,000," Poilievre shot back, citing a Toronto Star article that "debunked" Singh's claim.

Poilievre added: "I appreciate neither Liberals or NDP are very good with math."

Singh wasn't having it: "You're clearly — you can count up to six, which is great. It's not high enough, though."

(In fact, the Star did debunk the six number, but it also debunked Poilievre's 200,000 figure, saying the real number was around 4,248.)

Poilievre accuses Carney of spouting Trudeau's notes

Poilievre spent much of the evening pushing the narrative that Carney is just an extension of Justin Trudeau's government. During a jab about the Liberals' cost-of-living policies, he said:

"Mr. Carney, Justin Trudeau's staffers are actually here with you at this debate in Montreal, writing the talking points that you are regurgitating into the microphone."

Carney reacted immediately: "Ouch. Oooh."

Even Blanchet jumped in: "That's painful."

Poilievre continued, "How can we possibly believe that you are any different than the previous 10 years of Liberal government?"

Carney clapped back with, "Look, I do my own talking points, thank you very much."

Carney mutters that Poilievre is 'here to learn'

Things got snarky in a segment about energy and climate, in which Poilievre was talking about industrial carbon taxes and asked Carney how much a carbon tax would add to the price of a car. Carney didn't give a number, and Poilievre pounced:

"Mr. Carney didn't answer my question. I asked how much would an industrial carbon tax on Canadian steel add to the price of a car. And he won't answer because he knows that it will be very expensive."

Singh jumped in: "But do you know the answer? You don't know the answer either, you're just throwing out random questions."

Poilievre tried to press on, adding, "It's thousands of dollars."

"You're just making it up though, you don't know," Singh interjected again.

In all the hubbub, Carney got in the mix too. "I actually do know the answer to that question," Carney added, laughing. "He's wrong."

As Poilievre tried to press on, Singh interrupted yet again: "It's a straw man argument to say, 'Do you know the price?' when you don't know the answer."

As they kept talking over each other, Carney quietly told Singh, "He's here to learn."

Carney reminds Poilievre: 'Justin Trudeau isn't here'

In the final open debate section, Poilievre returned to a familiar target — Trudeau — criticizing Carney for the "inflationary policies that you advised Justin Trudeau to implement."

Carney's response was simple, but cutting: "I know you want to be running against Justin Trudeau."

"Justin Trudeau isn't here."

Whether you watched live or are just catching up now, this federal leaders' debate definitely had its popcorn moments. With just over a week to go before the 2025 election, the heat is on — and clearly, the gloves are off.

Love this? Check out our Narcity noticeboard for details on jobs, benefits, travel info and more!

AI tools may have been used to support the creation or distribution of this content; however, it has been carefully edited and fact-checked by a member of Narcity's Editorial team. For more information on our use of AI, please visit our Editorial Standards page.

  • Narcity Staff will keep you up to date with notices that impact Canadians from coast to coast to coast. From government payments and food recalls to national rankings, cost of living stats and minimum wage updates, all stories are carefully chosen and compiled for you by Narcity journalists dedicated to keeping you informed. Whether you're checking local and national weather reports, deals and discounts, gas prices or job alerts, you can rely on us to keep you informed with trustworthy, relevant articles.

6 of the spiciest moments from the federal leaders' French-language debate

One leader definitely wasn't afraid to throw shade. 🌶️

Mark Carney declares Canada's old relationship with the US 'is over' in dramatic victory speech

"President Trump is trying to break us so that America can own us."

Doug Ford responded to Mark Carney's election win with a giant 'to-do' list for the new PM

Doug Ford says Ontario is ready to help "unleash" Canada's economy.

This enchanting small town set on a BC island was named among North America's 'most peaceful'

Sandy beaches, ancient forests and a cozy town — anyone?. 🌲

New data reveals the 'most peaceful' places to live and Canadian towns demolished US ones

Five Canadian towns were named the most serene on the continent. 🍁

This Ontario gem with waterfront towns and beaches is one of Canada's 'best' spots to live

It has "large" homes "priced much lower" than major Canadian cities.