Redditors Tried To Name The Most Canadian City In Canada & Toronto Didn't Make The Cut

These smaller towns got a big shout-out though! 👇

A sign from the show Schitt's Creek. Right: Downtown Winnipeg.

A sign from the show Schitt's Creek. Right: Downtown Winnipeg.

Creator

What does it mean to live in a truly Canadian city?

Well, there are a lot of ways to understand that idea. And that's probably what led one Reddit user on a community called r/AskACanadian to pose the question.

"What is the most Canadianiest (sic) city in Canada?" asked the Reddit user.

Members of the community had some thoughts.

The comment at the very top advocated for the Manitoban capital of Winnipeg.


Another user wholeheartedly agreed with that comment, stating, "I feel like it has the right mix of pride and self-loathing to represent the country."


And proving that Winnipeg might just be the "Canadianiest" city of them all, others chimed in too.

"I’m born and raised in Edmonton and have only been to Winnipeg once, for a total of two days," said one user. "Winnipeg immediately came to mind when reading this question."

So, big ups to the Peg for being super Canadian!

Some Redditors got super creative and mentioned the fictional town of Schitt's Creek from the hit sitcom as well as Sunnyvale Trailer Park from Trailer Park Boys.

They really do fit the bill. If only they were real.

"I don't think there is an answer, different regions of Canada all have different vibes and there is none that is more Canadian than another," said another user.

"Maybe if discussing uniqueness, Montréal is a very unique place in Canada and in North America," they added.

And, to be honest, that's a very fair take.

This spurred some conversation about the question itself. One user called out the "assumption that Canada is a homogenous concept".


Another agreed, saying, "It’s all good. There are no bad parts of Canada. It’s beautiful in every region."

In reference to the iconic The Tragically Hip song, one person called out the small Ontario community of Bobcaygeon, the place where the "constellations reveal themselves one star at a time."

Other honourable mentions included Moose Jaw and North Battleford in Saskatchewan, Dryden and Ottawa in Ontario, Banff and Medicine Hat in Alberta.

Sorry, Toronto and Vancouver, it looks like you missed the mark.

Just another reason to visit some of Canada's underrated cities and explore what the country has to offer.

This article's cover image was used for illustrative purposes only.

  • Creator

    Tristan Wheeler (he/him) was a Toronto-based Creator for Narcity Media. He graduated from the University of British Columbia in 2020 where he was the Blog & Opinion Editor at the campus publication, The Ubyssey, for two years. Since then, his work has appeared in publications such as Curiocity, Maclean's, POV Magazine, and The Capital Daily, delving into topics such as film, media criticism, food & drink, podcasting, and more.

These Ontario spots made the world's best cities ranking and beat so many destinations

One city in Ontario is Canada's highest-ranking location. 👀

Canadians will be able to get Canadian Tire Money with their Tim Hortons orders soon

Here's what you need to know about this Canadian collab! 🇨🇦☕

A burst of snow will bring up to 20 cm to Ontario this week before the cold snap ends

Temperatures will warm up but still be cold enough for "lingering" snow.

13 Canadian tax credits you could claim when filing your return this year

Some credits reduce the tax you owe and others get you money back! 🤑

Some Canadians who bought Taylor Swift tickets on StubHub could be eligible for a full refund

A deal has been reached with StubHub Canada after an investigation into the company's ticket sales practices.

CSIS is hiring for these jobs in Ontario that pay up to $120,000 a year

Some positions don't require a university degree or a college diploma.

Ontario storm is bringing ice, flooding, power outages, thunderstorms & up to 20 cm of snow

Ontario's weather this week is shaping up to be an absolute mess.

Carney is now 2 seats from a majority after another floor crossing, with 3 more up for grabs

The Liberals are now two seats away from a majority with three by-elections next month.

Canadian serial killer Allan Legere, the 'Monster of the Miramichi,' has died in prison

The 78-year-old convicted murderer and rapist was serving a life sentence.

An ice storm threatens 20 mm of freezing rain and warnings are in effect for parts of Ontario

Power outages and property damage are likely because of ice build-up.