I Tried Tim Hortons vs Starbucks New Peppermint Hot Chocolate & This Is My Honest Opinion

'Tis the season for taste testing! With Starbucks' peppermint hot chocolate coming out and Tim Hortons' candy cane hot chocolate back on the menu, I tried both to see which one reigns supreme. 

Whether it's the looks, the taste, or the amount of holiday cheer, this is my honest opinion of these seasonal sippers. 

Editor's Choice: A New 'Family Photo' Of Justin Trudeau & World Leaders For The G20 Has The PM Standing Out

What do they look like? 

[rebelmouse-image 26001889 photo_credit="Elizabeth Keith | Narcity" expand=1 original_size="4032x3024"] Elizabeth Keith | Narcity

This time of year doesn't just mean holiday beverages but it also includes festive packaging too. 

For Starbucks, that means a green cup with seasonally coloured polka dots and green branded ribbon wrapping around it all. 

Tim Hortons took a simple approach with a white cup and their typically red logo but to make it merry, they added a sprig of holly and some extra text around it so now it reads "It's the most wonderful Tims of the year." 

Once you open the lids, however, it's pretty lacklustre. If either of these drinks had whip cream on them at any point, as they do in the promo pics, it's long gone. 

Also, the Starbucks cup already looked a little empty. 

What do they taste like? 

[rebelmouse-image 26001890 photo_credit="Elizabeth Keith | Narcity" expand=1 original_size="4032x3024"] Elizabeth Keith | Narcity

Neither of these drinks is overly impressive. While Starbucks' version isn't overly chocolatey, Tims' take isn't overly minty. 

The first one definitely has more mint flavour to it and even leaves a slight seasonal aftertaste. However, the chocolate doesn't really stand out. Starbucks doesn't make them overly sweet either. 

Tims, on the other hand, leans into the chocolate flavour and the sweetness that comes with it. The mint, though, is a bit M.I.A. When I started with the smell test, I only got their regular hot chocolate aromas and nothing candy cane at all. 

I was happy to see it had a bit of the festive flavours, and again a slight minty aftertaste, but it was also underwhelming.

Which one's the winner? 

Obviously, neither of the drinks stood out but if I have to pick a winner I am going to go with Tim Hortons. 

It might be my Canadian bias or the childhood nostalgia of ordering these as a kid, but I just found this one put me more into the festive spirit than Starbucks' version. 

Not to mention, the price difference! While Tims costs you $2.82 with tax for a medium, a tall (the smallest size) from Starbucks will set you back $5.02 with tax. 

Plus, I'm a sucker for a good pun so Tims' packaging won me over. 

Unfortunately, the other potential contender in this seasonal showdown, McDonald's, has opted not to do a holiday menu this year so we'll never know if it gets better than this. 

At the end of the day though, neither of them are bad. You could easily sip on both of these drinks to warm you up on a cold day, and that's my honest opinion.  

The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect the views of Narcity Media.

It may not be too long before you walk into your local Starbucks and grab a coffee without speaking to a single person.

The coffee chain is testing out a new store concept in New York City called Starbucks Pickup with Amazon Go.

Keep Reading Show less
Megan Renaud | Narcity, @nourhbib | Instagram

The Savoy Brasserie is hosting their own Christmas pop-up bar this year, and the cocktail names alone will have you running out the door to go.

The holiday festivities will be in full swing from December 1 to December 24. This includes a holiday drink menu and meal features.

Keep Reading Show less

McDonald's Holiday Drinks Are Finally Back In Canada After Not Being Available Last Year

It's been a while without the peppermint-flavoured drinks! ☕

'Tis the season! McDonald's holiday drinks are finally back in Canada and it's been a long time without them because they weren't available last year.

For anyone who wants to get into the holiday spirit, there are two hot festive beverages being offered at McDonald's locations in Canada right now, the Peppermint Mocha and the Peppermint Hot Chocolate.

Keep Reading Show less

Narcity may receive a small commission if you purchase something we recommend in this article, which was created by the Narcity Shop team. Items are in stock and prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time.

There are many things to love about this time of year and Starbucks' holiday drink menu is certainly one of them.

Keep Reading Show less