A Woman Is Calling Out A New York Restaurant That Serves An Entire Head Of Lettuce As A Salad

"They should have paid you for making it."

A caesar salad from Basta Pasta in New York. Right: A person cutting up the salad from Basta Pasta.

A caesar salad from Basta Pasta in New York. Right: A person cutting up the salad from Basta Pasta.

Texas Staff Writer

An Italian restaurant in New York City is going viral on social media because of its unique salad plating method, which has people shocked at the price.

New Yorker Mish Lim (@mishlim.star) recently posted a TikTok video of the caesar salad she ordered from Basta Pasta in the Flatiron District, calling it the "worst in NYC."

The video posted on Tuesday has gained 2 million views and shows Lim's plate with an entire head of lettuce sitting on top of the dressing, along with four sliced cherry tomatoes and three crouton sticks.

@mishlim.star

NYC salad #ceasarsalad #nycsalad #nyceats #thingstodoinnyc #nycfood #nycrestaurants #nyclife

"When I ordered the salad, I was not expecting a head of lettuce just chilling on the plate," she said in the popular post. "I had to cut it up myself, and it did not say 'DIY' caesar on the menu."

Basta Pasta's menu shows that the $12 Insalata Caeser comes with a "whole baby romaine heart." The description had commenters discussing whether the menu gave the plate a fair representation of what you're served.

"Did they think they were doing a wedge salad ?" one user wrote in the comment section of the previously mentioned video.

The comment section on Lim's TikTok video.The comment section on Lim's TikTok video.mishlim.star | TikTok

Although the menu does include the "whole" vegetable, viewers think it is vague and should specify that you have to cut the entire thing yourself to enjoy it instead of it coming chopped for you.

Its $12 price was another shock to the viewers, who believe the plate is too pricy for having to do all the work to slice it up.

"They should have paid you for making it," another view chimed in.

Narcity reached out to Basta Pasta for a comment regarding their salad, and we will update the article when we receive a response.

  • Staff Writer

    Brittany Cristiano (she/her) was Narcity USA's first full-time Texas Staff Writer. She's a lifelong Houstonian but enjoys every corner of the Lone Star State. Brittany is passionate about highlighting the beauty and rarities in the places we live in or visit–whether it’s showing North American readers something they never knew existed in the South, or helping Texans appreciate the beauty that’s been there the whole time. Oh, and she also loves to spill the tea on the latest trending figures in Texas and beyond. She previously served as an Editorial Intern for Houstonia magazine and as Editor-in-Chief of the University of St. Thomas’ student newspaper.

8 new food recalls were issued in Canada and some are linked to a huge salmonella outbreak

The salmonella-linked recall now includes over 70 varieties of deli meat. 🫣

11 gorgeous Toronto restaurants that locals say are always worth the splurge

Remember these spots for your next special occasion! 😍

Tax brackets in Canada: Here's what you'll pay in each province on your 2025 tax return

A few tax changes for 2025 mean you could be paying a lot less this spring. 👀

Costco has a new store opening in 2026 and the unique warehouse is a first in this province

It'll have thousands of products that aren't available at regular stores. 👀

24 products at Costco you can get for cheaper than items at Loblaws

You might not expect some of these items to be a better deal because of the price tags. 👀