I Tried 5 Craig's Cookies Flavours To Find The Best One & This Is My Honest Opinion

This Toronto spot will bring your cookie game to the next level. 🍪
Ontario Editor
Craig's Cookies: I Tried 5 Flavours & This Is My Honest Opinion

If you're from Toronto, you've probably spotted one of the many Craig's Cookies locations across the 6ix. 

The shop, which offers a variety of mouthwatering flavours, puts a creative twist on the traditional dessert. 

While the combination of cookies seems endless, it's important to note that flavours may vary depending on which location you visit. 

I choose the top five flavours that sounded the most appealing to me and put them to the test. 

Editor's Choice: Pinterest Is Looking To Fill Over 50 Jobs In Toronto This Year & The Perks Are Next Level

5. Toffee Cookie

This cookie has the perfect combination of salty and sweet, but it pales in comparison to the rest.

The thin and brittle dessert is very similar to something that you may find at a local bake sale or something that your mom made.

While it's still a cookie that I would eat without a complaint, it leaves me unsatisfied and gives me no "wow" factor.

4. Chocolate-Covered Raisin Cookie

If you're a fan of chocolate chip raisin cookies, this bad boy won't disappoint.

The outside is the perfect balance of crunch, while the inside tastes like you're eating pure cookie dough (in a good way.)

While there are no complaints about this simple cookie, I've ranked it lower on the list simply because it does contain raisins.

And even if you're a dried fruit fan, the chocolaty creations that are coming up next are hands down way better.

3. M&M Cookie

This M&M cookie is nothing like the stale ones you would eat in primary school.

It's savoury, sweet and moist (yes, I said moist) all at the same time.

However, the M&M's are so melted into the cookie it is hard to differentiate between this treat and just a regular chocolate chip cookie.

2. Peanut Butter Cup Cookie

Coming in second is the peanut butter cup cookie, which tastes exactly how you would expect it to.

The sweet flavours of the chocolate balance out nicely with the richness of the cookie and saltiness of the peanut butter.

Overall, it is a cookie that I would reach for again.

1. Mars Bar Cookie 

There is nothing bad that can be said about this cookie (unless you start thinking about calories).

Taking a bite of this mouthwatering creation feels like you're eating two desserts at once.

The Mars Bar is stuffed into the middle and the caramel center oozes out with every bite.

In my honest opinion, this cookie transports me back to the days of crazy treats at the CNE and easily tops the rest.

The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not reflect the views of Narcity Media.

Allysha Howse
Ontario Editor
Recommended For You