Amber Heard Wants Johnny Depp's Trial Win Tossed Out & Her Lawyers Say $10M Is 'Excessive'

It's not over yet 👀

Amber Heard in court. Right: Johnny Depp leaving court.

Amber Heard in court. Right: Johnny Depp leaving court.

Courtesy of Court TV
Interim Deputy Editor (News)

Amber Heard might've lost her court battle against ex-husband Johnny Depp, but she's not ready to accept it yet.

Heard's lawyers have officially asked a judge to throw out the jury verdict that sided with Depp in early June, saying the jury wasn't vetted properly and that the $10.35 million she was ordered to pay is "excessive."

Lawyers for Heard, 36, filed a post-trial motion to dismiss Depp's lawsuit and order a new trial on Friday, documents show.

It's the latest twist in the Depp v. Heard case, which played out in front of cameras over a six-week period earlier this year. Depp ultimately convinced a jury that Heard defamed him with a 2018 Washington Post op-ed, in which she claimed to be a "public figure representing domestic abuse."

Heard never mentioned Depp by name in that piece, but his lawyers convinced the jury that it clearly pointed to him anyway. The jury ended up siding with Depp on all three parts of his defamation case against Heard, awarding him $15 million in damages as a result. The judge later knocked that down to $10.35 million.

Heard counter-sued in the case and won $2 million in damages for convincing the jury of one part of her case.

Both actors had accused one another of abuse during their relationship, which ended in divorce in 2016.

Now, her lawyers argue that Depp did not back up his claims of defamation with evidence, and they want a judge to toss the whole thing out and order a new trial for Heard's claims.

"Instead, the evidence overwhelmingly supported Ms. Heard believed she was the victim of abuse at the hands of Mr. Depp," they wrote in the motion.

Heard's lawyers also want the judge to look into how the jury was selected. They claim there was a "discrepancy" with one juror's date of birth and that it points to possible issues in how the jury was vetted.

The two sides were given a few weeks to try to reach a settlement that would knock Heard's final bill down a bit, but they failed to do so by their June 24 deadline.

Her lawyers have already signalled that she can't pay the amount she owes and that she would likely appeal.

Depp's team hasn't commented on the motion yet, the Associated Press reports.

  • Interim Deputy Editor, News

    Josh Elliott (he/him) was the Interim Deputy Editor (News) for Narcity, where he led the talented editorial team's local news content. Josh previously led Narcity’s international coverage and he spent several years as a writer for CTV and Global News in the past. He earned his English degree from York University and his MA in journalism from Western University. Superhero content is his kryptonite.

Judge orders pause on Alberta separation process

Judge orders temporary pause on Alberta separation referendum petition process

Eby says he's 'moving forward' with First Nations

Eby 'moving forward' with First Nations after latest climbdown on Indigenous law

A Silk and Great Value plant-based beverage class action has reached a $6.5M settlement

Here's what you need to know about how much money you could receive.

Gas exposure at pool linked with mixing chemicals

City spokesperson says Crystal Pool is safe again, but remains closed until Tuesday

Gunman at Mexico pyramids kills Canadian tourist

Canadian tourist killed, another injured after gunman opens fire at Mexico pyramids

Alberta to do away with twice-a-year time change

Alberta's government says it will do away with twice-a-year time change

Poll suggests more Tory voters now want new leader

Poll suggests more Conservative voters now want to replace Poilievre as leader

Ontario to sell $29-million jet bought for Ford

Ontario to sell $29-million jet bought for Premier Doug Ford after backlash

Canada, Mercosur look to sign trade deal in 2026

Canada, Mercosur aiming to sign free trade deal this year: Brazilian official