12 Kirkland Signature items I won't buy at Costco even though they're cheap name-brand dupes

I don't mind paying more for some name brands!

person holding bottle of kirkland signature olive oil at costco. right: jars of kirkland signature hazelnut spread at costco

Kirkland Signature olive oil. Right: Kirkland Signature hazelnut spread.

Senior Writer

The views expressed in this Opinion article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Narcity Media.

Costco has a lot of Kirkland Signature products that are cheap dupes of name-brand items at the wholesale retailer and grocery stores in Canada.

Despite the lower prices, a few of the store-brand items don't get added to my shopping cart.

Kirkland Signature is Costco's private label that offers shoppers "the highest quality standards at the lowest possible prices."

But just because the cost is lower for many of these items doesn't mean I buy them.

There are some name-brand products that I prefer to pay more for at Costco and grocery stores.

So, here are a dozen Kirkland Signature products at Costco Canada stores that I won't put in my shopping cart.

French roast coffee

bags of \u200bKirkland Signature French roast coffee at costco

Kirkland Signature French roast coffee.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

Costco has a 1.13-kilogram bag of Kirkland Signature French roast whole bean coffee for $24.99.

Even though it's cheaper than name-brand coffee, I still prefer to get the name-brand items at Costco or grocery stores because there are more options, especially with ground coffee.

Hazelnut spread

jars of \u200bKirkand Signature hazelnut spread at costco

Kirkand Signature hazelnut spread.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $16.99 two one-kilogram jars of Kirkland Signature hazelnut spread.

A pack of two one-kilogram jars of Nutella costs $17.99 at Costco.

The Kirkland product is a dollar cheaper, but it doesn't compare to the taste of Nutella, in my opinion. So, I'll always buy the name-brand item at Costco.

Honey

bottles of \u200bKirkland Signature honey at costco

Kirkland Signature honey.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

Costco has a pack of three 750-gram bottles of Kirkland Signature liquid honey for $19.99.

I don't use that much honey and don't want to keep three big bottles in the pantry, so I prefer to get a smaller bottle of name-brand Billy Bee honey at the grocery store, even though it's more expensive.

Cream cheese

person holding pack of Kirkland Signature cream cheese at costco

Kirkland Signature cream cheese.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $9.99 for a pack of four 250-gram blocks of Kirkland Signature cream cheese.

Costco also has name-brand Philadelphia cream cheese for $13.49, and it comes in a pack with two 500-gram tubs.

The store-brand dupe is $3.50 cheaper than the name-brand product.

It might not seem like a good enough reason, but I actually prefer to pay more for the name-brand Philadelphia cream cheese at Costco because it comes in tubs.

Ice cream bars

boxes of Kirkland Signature vanilla almond ice cream bars at costco

Kirkland Signature vanilla almond ice cream bars.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $16.99 for a box of Kirkland Signature vanilla almond ice cream that comes with 18 bars, which works out to $0.94 per bar.

Costco also has name-brand Häagen-Dazs vanilla almond ice cream. It costs $13.99 for a box that comes with nine bars, which works out to $1.55 per bar.

It's cheaper to buy the Kirkland product when the price is broken down by the size of the product, but Costco's store brand version is too big, in my opinion.

If I want to get ice cream bars when shopping at Costco, I put the Häagen-Dazs box in my shopping cart.

Balsamic vinegar

bottles of \u200bKirkland Signature balsamic vinegar

Kirkland Signature balsamic vinegar.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

Costco has a one-litre bottle of Kirkland Signature balsamic vinegar for $20.49.

Even if that price is a better deal than name-brand balsamic vinegar at grocery stores, I still buy it at the grocery store because the sizes are smaller.

Olive oil

person holding bottle of \u200bKirkland Signature olive oil at costco

Kirkland Signature olive oil.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $21.99 for a two-litre bottle of Kirkland Signature extra virgin olive oil at Costco.

At grocery stores, name-brand versions of extra virgin olive oil can be $30 or more, but I still prefer the name brands over Kirkland.

Chocolate-covered granola bars

boxes of \u200bKirkland Signature chocolate-covered granola bars at costco

Kirkland Signature chocolate-covered granola bars.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

Costco has chocolate-covered granola bars that are dupes of Quaker Dipps granola bars.

A 1.49-kilogram box with 48 granola bars costs $16.99.

I don't put this item in my cart when shopping at Costco. I get a smaller box at the grocery store because the Kirkland product is too much for one person, and the smaller boxes from the grocery store are easier to store in the pantry.

Microwave popcorn

boxes of Kirkland Signature microwave popcorn at costco

Kirkland Signature microwave popcorn.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $19.99 for a box of Kirkland Signature microwave popcorn with 44 bags, which works out to $0.45 per bag.

Even though the Kirkland product seems more expensive because the name-brand Orville Redenbacher microwave popcorn is $11.49, it's actually cheaper.

It comes with just 24 bags, which works out to $0.47 per bag.

Since the price difference isn't huge, I prefer to buy the name-brand microwave popcorn because Costco's Kirkland Signature product is too oversized.

Tissues

boxes of \u200bKirkland Signature facial tissues at costco

Kirkland Signature facial tissues.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

It costs $22.99 for a pack of Kirkland Signature tissues that comes with 12 boxes of three-ply tissues.

When I shop at Costco, I prefer to get a pack of name-brand Scotties tissues that comes with 21 boxes of two-ply tissues.

It only costs a few more dollars at $27.99.

Also, three-ply tissues aren't always as luxurious as they seem, in my opinion.

Toilet paper

packs of \u200bKirkland Signature toilet paper at costco

Kirkland Signature toilet paper.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

A pack of Kirkland Signature toilet paper costs $23.99 at Costco, and it comes with 30 rolls.

That's cheaper than a lot of name-brand bathroom tissue products at Costco and grocery stores, but I like the smaller packs that are easier to keep in the linen closet and the bathroom vanity, so I buy those at the grocery store.

Laundry detergent

bottles of \u200bKirkland Signature laundry detergent at costco

Kirkland Signature laundry detergent.

Lisa Belmonte | Narcity

Costco has a 5.73-litre bottle of Kirkland Signature laundry detergent for $19.99, and it's a dupe of Tide laundry detergent.

When I need laundry detergent, I get a smaller bottle at the grocery store, even if the price tag is higher and it costs more money per 100 millilitres than the oversized Kirkland product.

These prices are confirmed at the time of publishing, but they can change at any time. Taxes and fees may not be included.

  • Senior Writer

    Lisa Belmonte (she/her) is a Senior Writer with Narcity Media. After graduating with a Bachelor of Journalism from Toronto Metropolitan University (formerly Ryerson University), she joined the Narcity team. Lisa covers news and notices from across the country from a Canada-wide perspective. Her early coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic earned Narcity its first-ever national journalism award nomination.

The new Canada Groceries and Essentials Benefit is paying out soon and you can get up to $717

This is a one-time top-up before it replaces the GST/HST credit.

Liberals' affordability benefit coming June 5

Federal Liberals' promised one-time affordability benefit coming June 5

Canada Post ending most door-to-door mail

Canada Post beginning work to end most door-to-door mail delivery

Drug overdose leading cause of maternal death: VCH

Nearly half of VCH maternal deaths within a year of birth caused by overdose: report

Carney announces new Canada Investment Summit

Carney announces new summit in Toronto aimed at attracting $1 trillion in investment