I tried Olivia Rodrigo's Crumbl cookies in Toronto and they seriously impressed

They're only here for a few days!

Madeline holding a bunch of cookies. Right: Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookie.

Madeline holding a bunch of cookies. Right: Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookie.

Lead Writer, Travel

The views expressed in this Opinion article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Narcity Media.

If you have a sweet tooth, I’ve got some news that will be "Good 4 U." Olivia Rodrigo has partnered with Crumbl Cookie to create an exclusive GUTS Cookie and it's now available in the Toronto area for a limited time.

Inspired by the singer-songwriter's GUTS Tour, the cookie is popping up at select Crumbl locations across North America.

Madeline holding a cookie.Madeline holding a cookie.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

"This collaboration marks a celebration of creativity and flavor, bringing fans a memorable experience that perfectly combines music and the Crumbl experience," Sawyer Hemsely, Chief Branding Officer and co-founder of Crumbl said in a press release.

It’s only available in the Toronto area for a few days in celebration of Olivia Rodrigo's tour stop on March 29 to 30.

I decided to try this cookie myself, and here's the lowdown on the taste, where to find it, and whether it lives up to the buzz.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

The cookie

As described in a press release, the GUTS Cookie consists of "two chilled purple vanilla cookies sandwiched around delicious layers of triple-berry jam and light vanilla buttercream, rolled in colorful star-studded sprinkles, and topped with a star cutout."

The treat is only available at Crumbl Heartland in Mississauga until March 30, 2024, so you don’t have long to get your hands on it.

The look

This cookie truly looks like it was made to be a star. The soft purple colour screams "Olivia Rodrigo" and the jam-filled star cutouts made me want to take a big bite.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

The buttercream frosting is neatly spread between the two cookies and covered with vibrant pink sprinkles that add a fun pop of colour.

I was shocked by how big and heavy the cookies are — this is no treat for the faint-hearted!

The taste

One bite of this cookie gave me "déjà vu" in all the best ways. The nostalgic sugar cookie and jam flavours transported me back to my childhood.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

The cookies are perfectly soft and fluffy, so it feels like biting into a cloud.

The buttercream is the real start of the show. I worried it might be grainy and overly sweet like some other icings can be, but it has a beautiful, smooth texture and just the right amount of sweetness.

The jam filling wasn’t overly sweet either and added a nice touch of fruitness and gooiness to the dessert.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

The delicate vanilla flavours and silky-smooth textures of the GUTS Cookie made it hard not to eat the whole thing in one go.

The sweetness isn’t overpowering and the filling to cookie ratio is on point.

Overall experience

Whether you’re an Olivia Rodrigo fan or just a fellow dessert lover, this cookie is worth a try, especially since it's only around for a limited time.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookies.Madeline Forsyth | Narcity

Given its size, it’s perfect for sharing or nibbling on throughout the day. I’ll admit, I had to exercise some major self-restraint not to reach for another one.

"It's a bad idea, right?" Eating a whole box in one go?

GUTS Cookie

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookie.

Olivia Rodrigo GUTS Cookie.

Courtesy of Crumbl

Price: $6.98 per cookie

When: Until March 30, 2024

Address: 5985 Rodeo Dr. #1a, Mississauga, ON

Crumbl Cookies website

This Review article is part of a Narcity Media series. The views expressed are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Narcity Media.

  • Lead Writer

    Madeline Forsyth is a Toronto-based Lead Writer for Narcity Media. After earning her B.A. (Hons) at Queen's University, she spent a year travelling much of the world as a flight attendant. Now, she uses her experience in the travel industry and passion for writing to share stories about buzzworthy events and adventures across Canada and the globe. Madeline has been published in PopSugar and has interviewed sports and entertainment personalities for Narcity. She has covered and photographed restaurant openings as well as event launches such as the world premiere of the Dr. Seuss Experience. Some of her favourite things to write about include charming small towns and anything to do with Harry Potter.

We shopped for 11 essentials at grocery stores in Canada to find the cheapest basket

There is a difference of almost $83 between the most and least expensive totals. 👀

A CRA employee was arrested for identity theft & info trafficking after a 4-year investigation

RCMP began investigating in 2022 after the CRA reported one of its employees had "compromised taxpayer information."

Northern lights are forecast across Canada this week because of a geomagnetic storm

Auroras during the spring equinox can be "the brightest and most colourful" of the year!

Canada is spending $1.4B to build munitions factories in Ontario & Quebec

The feds are looking to build up the domestic supply of heavy artillery shells and reduce Canada's reliance on foreign suppliers.

Canada's population dropped in 2025 for the first time in recorded history — Here's why

Statistics Canada says the drop is primarily due to a massive immigration slowdown.

The feds are appealing after Emergencies Act use during 'Freedom Convoy' was ruled unlawful

After multiple rulings that the use of the act breached Charter rights, the government is taking its appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada.