Ontario Cities With The Cheapest Car Insurance Have Been Revealed & These 8 Top The List

It's almost half of what other cities pay! 👀

Toronto Associate Editor

There's nothing quite like getting your full licence and hitting the road on your own for the first time. But that excitement is quickly overshadowed by the costs that come along with it — and let's face it, Ontario car insurance can be pretty pricey.

However, while rates typically run high in areas around the GTA, some cities across the province pay way less than others.

A new report from RATESDOTCA breaks down what Ontarians are paying for their car insurance, and some spots cost almost half of what others are paying.

On average, Ontarians paid $1,555 in 2021, which actually dropped down by $61 from the year before in 2020.

Kingston, Cornwall, Elizabethtown, Amherstview, Gananoque, Martintown, Iroquois and Brockville are tied for the cheapest car insurance rate in all of Ontario. Drivers here shelled out roughly $1,132 in 2021 for their car insurance fees, which is $423 less than the average rate.

Car owners in Port Hope, Belleville, Cobourg, Trenton, Kendal, Napanee and Picton cough up about $1,175 each year, while those in Cloyne, Kemptville and Smiths Falls pay roughly $1,185.

Even though these areas pay the least, all of them except for Belleville, Trenton and Kendal saw their rates go up from last year.

So, who is getting slammed with the highest fees?

Here are the priciest cities for car insurance in Ontario:

  1. Vaughan — $2,179
  2. Ajax — $2,104
  3. Richmond Hill — $2,025
  4. Brampton — $1,976
  5. Mississauga — $1,971
  6. Pickering — $1,959
  7. Toronto — $1,953
  8. Oshawa — $1,833
  9. Whitby — $1,792
  10. Nobleton, Schomberg, Orangeville, King City — $1,766
RATESDOTCA notes that these estimates are not averages, but rather "are based on a 35-year-old male who drives a 2018 Honda Civic four-door with a clean driving record."
But insurance rates did dip down on average in 2021. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the report said insurance companies gave rebates and financial support, and drivers also cut down on their coverage since they weren't commuting to work as much anymore.

This article's cover image was used for illustrative purposes only.

  • Toronto Associate EditorAlex Arsenych (she/her) was a Calgary-based Associate Editor at Narcity Canada, covering everything from what's trending across the country to what's happening near you. On top of her Bachelor of Journalism, Alex graduated with a history degree from the University of Toronto. She's passionate about past and present events and how they shape our world. Alex has been published at Now Magazine, Much, MTV, and MTV Canada.

Here's how much it actually costs to live in Toronto vs. 9 other spots in Ontario

You could save over $11K a year by moving an hour and a half away. 👀

Ontario's cheapest cities were revealed and you could save $26,000/year by leaving Toronto

Here's what income you need for a "comfortable" life in 36 cities across Ontario. 👇

Canada's housing market is set to get cheaper and 5 cities are dropping more than Toronto

A buyer's market is finally taking shape across much of Canada. 🏡

Gas prices in Canada are dropping in a bunch of cities tomorrow — but rising in a few others

Here's where to fill up today vs. wait for a better deal tomorrow. 👇

The White House released an AI video insulting Canada and Brady Tkachuk is firing back

The video depicts the Ottawa Senators captain calling Canadians "maple syrup eating f---s."

Canadian father detained by ICE for months says he got 1 frozen waffle in 24 hours

He's been a permanent resident of the U.S. for nearly 30 years.

Ontario man accused of assaulting a crossbow-wielding home intruder has charges withdrawn

"If a guy breaks into your house and he has a crossbow ready to kill you, it's free game," Premier Doug Ford said.

Canada is predicted to see zero population growth in 2026 after massive immigration cuts

Temporary work and student visas have been cut nearly in half.