Costco Took A Cake Order Way Too Literally & Internet Users Are Cracking Up At The Result

"Costco will give you exactly what you know you didn't need."

A Costco Kirkland-branded bakery. Right: A Costco cake design request that has gone viral.

A Costco Kirkland-branded bakery. Right: A Costco cake design request that has gone viral.

Interim Deputy Editor (News)

A Costco cake decorator just proved that even the best instructions can be taken the wrong way after turning a customer’s simple request into a viral internet moment.

A Reddit user shared three photos over the weekend showing a Costco cake request along with the final result, and someone clearly should've asked them to hold the Kirkland Signature sass.

It's unclear if the poster was the person who ordered the cake, but they did include a photo of the cake order form so you can see exactly how much Costco screwed it up.

"Costco will give you exactly what you know you didn't need," reads the post title in Reddit's MildlyInfuriating community, where it's been upvoted tens of thousands of times.

According to the post, a customer simply asked for a white half-sheet Costco cake with red frosting all around its edges. The order form shows that they wanted no designs and no writing, and on the back of the form they included more instructions.

Costco special order cake form. U/amungus45 | Reddit

"Only request red frosting on perimeter for top/bottom," they wrote. Then, just to make it crystal clear, they drew a crude three-dimensional slab cake using marker to show the edges with frosting.

They clearly underestimated (or overestimated?) the staff at Costco, because someone took that drawing and ran with it.

Instead of delivering a cake with red frosting on its edges, Costco's cake designer made an all-white slab cake with one thing on it: the customer's crappy cake drawing.

That's right: They drew a cake on a cake, and they even made it look janky like the original drawing.

U/amungus45 | Reddit

"The good news is they did read both pages of instructions," reads the top comment on the post, which generated a bunch of hilarious responses.

"Read one side, glanced at the other," joked another user.

One user hailed it as an act of "malicious compliance," while another pointed out that the cake designer got one thing right: they used black and red icing on the edges that the customer requested.

Many were also impressed that the cake designer drew the box "a little off just like in the picture. Took some effort."

"Honestly, I'm pretty impressed by how close the drawing is to the figure you drew," wrote another.

It's unclear if the customer got a refund for the aggressively literal design, but keep this in mind the next time you try to order a cake for yourself. You never know how someone else is going to take your sh*tty drawing!

This article's left-hand cover image was used for illustrative purposes only.

  • Interim Deputy Editor, News

    Josh Elliott (he/him) was the Interim Deputy Editor (News) for Narcity, where he led the talented editorial team's local news content. Josh previously led Narcity’s international coverage and he spent several years as a writer for CTV and Global News in the past. He earned his English degree from York University and his MA in journalism from Western University. Superhero content is his kryptonite.

A Silk and Great Value plant-based beverage class action has reached a $6.5M settlement

Here's what you need to know about how much money you could receive.

This weather system will bring up to 25 cm of snow to southern Ontario in the next few days

Lake-effect snow, freezing temperatures, and strong winds are forecast.

9 federal tax credits that could reduce how much you owe on your tax return this year

If you don't want to owe the government money, these tax credits could help!

Judge orders pause on Alberta separation process

Judge orders temporary pause on Alberta separation referendum petition process

University of Alberta has free courses you can take online that have interesting subjects

You can learn about dinosaurs, black holes, mountains, the arctic, and more!

Man accused in Ryan Wedding case seeks bail review

Ontario jeweller accused in Ryan Wedding case challenges decision to deny him bail

Liberals support banning kids from social media

Liberal party adopts motion to ban kids under 16 from social media